Why Your Local Competitors' Websites Convert More Customers

Hoi, ik ben Karina en dit is Design by Karina.

In today’s fast-paced digital world, your small business website is often the first impression potential customers get of your business. If you're a small business owner, it’s crucial to understand why your local competitors might be attracting more customers — and the answer often lies in their optimized websites that convert visitors into customers.

I’ve spent years designing websites, including my time working as a product designer at Uber. In my experience, certain elements can make or break a website’s conversion rate. When I transitioned from corporate product design to helping small businesses like yours, I noticed that many local businesses overlook key aspects of website design that could transform their sites into powerful sales machines.

Here are 10 reasons why your competitors’ websites convert more customers — and how you can make the necessary changes to compete.

1. Optimized for Mobile: Your Customers Are On Their Phones

We’ve all been there — you visit a website on your phone, and everything’s out of place. Text is too small, buttons are hard to tap — frustrating, right? Your competitors know this, which is why their websites are fully optimized for mobile devices.

With more people browsing and buying through their phones than ever before, if your site isn’t designed for mobile users, you’re losing business.

Tip: Test your website on your smartphone. Are the buttons easy to click? Is the text readable? If not, it’s time for a mobile-friendly redesign. Small businesses that optimize their sites for mobile often see a significant spike in conversions.

2. Clear Call-to-Actions (CTAs) That Guide Customers

Many small business websites hide or overlook their CTAs, but not your competitors. They use bold, action-oriented CTAs like “Book a Free Consultation” or “Get Your Free Quote Today.” These CTAs guide visitors to take action, converting them into customers.

At Uber, we spent months testing different CTA styles and placements to boost driver signups. Similarly, on your website, a clear, well-placed CTA can make all the difference in converting visitors.

Tip: Place CTAs strategically — after a service description, on your homepage, or within your portfolio. Action-oriented CTAs drive engagement and conversions.

3. User-Centered Design (UCD): It’s All About the Customer

Your competitors are putting the customer first in their website design, making it easy for visitors to navigate, find what they need, and take action. A user-centered design is the key to a website that converts.

When I worked at Uber, we focused on creating seamless experiences for users. Apply the same principle to your website — is it easy for first-time visitors to find your services? Do they know how to contact you?

Tip: Walk through your website as if you were a new visitor. Is everything clear and straightforward? If not, consider simplifying the design to focus on user experience.

4. Professional Visual Design Instills Trust

Imagine walking into a cluttered, poorly lit store — you’d likely leave immediately. Websites work the same way. Your competitors invest in professional, polished visual design that aligns with their brand and builds trust.

For example, I helped a local bakery revamp their outdated, cluttered website. The modern design boosted their online orders within weeks.

Tip: Invest in good visuals and branding. Your website doesn’t need to be flashy, but it should look clean, professional, and trustworthy.

5. High-Quality Content That Speaks to Customer Needs

Your competitors use carefully crafted content that addresses the needs and concerns of their target audience, turning visitors into customers.

I redesigned a website for a local painter, focusing on answering clients’ most common questions. The result? More inquiries and higher conversion rates.

Tip: Don’t just list your services. Think about your customers’ pain points and how your business solves them. Use your content to answer those questions.

6. Fast Loading Speeds Keep Customers Engaged

A slow website frustrates users and pushes them towards your competitors. Your competitors know that fast-loading websites not only improve user experience but also rank higher in search results.

At Uber, I learned that a one-second delay in load time can significantly reduce conversions. The same applies to your small business website.

Tip: Use tools like Google PageSpeed Insights to check your website’s speed. If it’s slow, optimize your images, minimize code, and enable browser caching.

7. SEO-Optimized Pages Get Them Found Online

Your competitors are ensuring that their websites rank higher on Google search results by investing in SEO (Search Engine Optimization). This means they’re attracting more visitors who are actively searching for their services.

I worked with a local electrician whose website was barely getting any traffic. After optimizing his site for local SEO, he saw an increase in inquiries and traffic.

Tip: Use the right keywords, optimize meta descriptions, and create high-quality content to ensure your site ranks higher in search results.

8. Customer Testimonials Build Instant Trust

Social proof is powerful. Your competitors are featuring testimonials and case studies to show potential customers that others trust and value their services.

I added customer testimonials to a local beauty salon’s website, and new clients mentioned how reading those reviews helped them decide to book.

Tip: Ask your happy customers for a testimonial and feature it on your website. It builds trust and credibility.

9. Seamless Contact Forms Make It Easy to Connect

Your competitors make it easy for potential clients to get in touch by featuring simple, accessible contact forms or booking systems. A seamless process is essential for conversions.

Many businesses I’ve worked with saw a significant increase in leads just by making their contact form more user-friendly.

Tip: Ensure your contact form or booking system is easy to find and even easier to use.

10. Consistent Updates Keep Things Fresh

Your competitors regularly update their websites with fresh content, new offers, and regular maintenance, keeping their sites relevant and engaging.

I worked with a local contractor who regularly updated his portfolio. Not only did this help his SEO, but it also showed potential clients that his business was active and successful.

Tip: Don’t let your website go stale. Regularly update it with new blog posts, projects, or offers.

Conclusion

Your competitors are converting more customers because they’ve taken the time to optimize their websites. But the good news is — so can you. With a few strategic changes, your small business website can attract visitors and convert them into loyal customers.

Ready to transform your website into a conversion machine? I’ve helped small businesses just like yours build high-converting websites, and I’d love to help you too. Contact me today for a free consultation, and let’s start building a website that converts!

Ready this blog post in Dutch: Click Here